|

google music

With the release of Google Play Music All Access the music subscription market has become even more crowded. Google might be a big name, but other services such as Spotify and Rdio are already popular. Does Google Play Music All Access (GPMAA) have what it takes to compete with these other choices? They each offer different prices, amount of songs, offline modes, and more. We’ll compare GPMAA, Spotify Premium, and Rdio subscriptions to see who’s best at what.

Price and what it gets you

Obviously a subscription is going to cost you some amount of money. Rdio and Spotify have several tiers of subscription, while GPMAA only has one at the moment. GPMAA costs $9.99/month, but those in the United States (The only location it is currently available) that sign up by June 30 will have a special discount at $7.99/month. It's worth noting that Google Play Music allows 20,000 song uploads even with the standard free version.

Even when free, Spotify offers unlimited songs on your computer but with periodic ads. For $4.99/month users can remove ads, and for $9.99/month they can go to Premium which includes unlimited mobile streaming and the ability to download music for offline listening. Spotify also has a 30 day trial for the $9.99/month Premium service.

Rdio has three subscription types. Web at $4.99/month allows unlimited streaming on your computer through the web or desktop apps. Unlimited at $9.99/month grants unlimited streaming on both web and mobile (this also opens up syncing to mobile for offline listening, covered later). Last, Unlimited Family grants the previous features to two users for $17.99/month, or three users at $22.99/month.

The prices are all pretty similar to each other, so it’s really a matter of what you receive for the cost. Unlimited streaming and syncing for offline on mobile makes Rdio stand out. If you happen to have two friends, the Rdio Unlimited Family subscription has quite a financial benefit. On the other hand you could also adopt GPMAA now to get a great discount.

Library size and sound quality

Both Spotify  and Rdio libraries contain more than 20 million songs, while GPMAA lags slightly behind with 18 million. That’s still an impressive amount of songs, and GPMAA includes major artists not on Spotify, such as Pink Floyd. GPMAA and Spotify also allow you to listen to your own personal library of songs, a feature Rdio lacks.

google music cloud

Spotify Premium does this by syncing songs on your local hard drive for playback. GPMAA on the other hand actually uploads music files to cloud storage, allowing download of those songs on other computers you log into (a maximum of ten). You can store up to 20,000 songs, each song being a maximum of 300 megabytes. This is a huge advantage for anyone who uses multiple computers and will want to transfer their collection elsewhere. Keep in mind files you download from the cloud are high quality MP3s, easily accessible on computers but slightly more hidden on mobile devices.

rdio bitrate

Both Spotify Premium and GPMAA cap sound quality at 320 kbps (Free Spotify accounts cap at 160 kbps), while Rdio hasn’t released exact bitrates as they experiment with encoding. All of these services can lower the bitrate if you are a slow connection or using wifi. In Spotify you can also manually lower the stream quality. At the moment Rdio’s secrecy makes it likely that their bitrate is lower than their competitors, putting it at a grave disadvantage.

Supported Apps

A big draw to streaming music is being able to listen to it anywhere you go. Each of the three services offers different supported apps.

spotify app

Spotify Premium finds its home primarily on the desktop app for Windows and Mac. There is also a web app, but it is currently in Beta and has minor issues (such as not being able to play your entire library or quickly sort playlists). Spotify Premium has mobile apps for iOS, Android, and Windows Phone. There is no official BlackBerry support at the moment.

rdio web app

Rdio Unlimited is accessed primarily as a web app, but there are desktop apps available for Mac and Windows. The service also has mobile apps on iOS, Android, and, Windows Phone. It also has a BlackBerry app, but not all devices work.

google music player

Finally, GPMAA is only currently available on the web and as an Android app. iOS support will arrive later, but for now there are already developers submitting independent apps to the iTunes App Store.

The app selection is slightly in favor of Spotify where it has a strong desktop client, can be accessed from the web,  and has apps  on multiple mobile devices. It only lacks BlackBerry support, which Rdio may cover.

Offline accessibility

You’re not always going to have a stable internet connection when you want to listen to your music. Each service has their own approach to offline music.

take spotify offline

Spotify Premium is fully ready to go offline on computers, iOS, and Android. Up to 3,333 songs can be taken into offline mode on up to three devices. The offline songs last for 30 days, after which they must be reconnect to verify their authenticity.

rdio screen

Rdio Unlimited can sync songs to mobile devices. The limit simply depends on your device’s amount of storage space and there doesn’t need to be a re-sync as with Spotify. However, Rdio cannot be taken offline to your computer, even if you have one of the desktop apps installed.

google music android

GPMAA can pin albums and playlists to the Android app, allowing offline listening on the go. There is currently no offline listening for the web version of GPMAA, but considering the ability to download from the cloud, the feature could arrive in the future.

At the moment Spotify’s ability to take so many songs offline at a time makes it top of the heap. However, it would be even better if there wasn’t the 30 day restriction before having to reconnect.

Social connection

One of the key features of Spotify is its ability to connect users and share music with each other. Rdio also has a set of social features, while GPMAA is nearly stand alone  - there is no way to follow playlists or spy on other users (Though you can share songs to Google+).

spotify social

Spotify claims that they have 24 million active users, 6 million which subscribe to Spotify Premium. The high amount of users is important as you can follow others, check out what they are listening to, and follow user playlists. You can also share songs to Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr, or directly to other Spotify users. Since Spotify used to have heavy Facebook integration, it’s likely to find a few friends that have Spotify accounts.

rdio reviews

Rdio hasn’t released their exact amount of users (they were hush about their bitrate after all), but they still have a wealth of social features such as viewing friends, check what they are listening to, and the ability to browse their collection. A nice touch is that users can write reviews for whole albums or individual songs, which Spotify could certainly adapt. As with Spotify you can share songs to Twitter, Facebook, or other Rdio users (You can’t share to Tumblr, though).

So which one is right for me?

So we’ve laid out aspects of these three services, but now it becomes a question of which one you should subscribe to. The three of them are very different programs, so it comes down to personal taste. We’ll summarize both the reasons you should pick each of them, and the drawbacks.

  • Spotify Premium - Spotify has great streaming sound quality, ability to sync 3,333 songs offline, and a strong social connection. It’s at its best in its desktop app on Windows and PC, but has apps for many other devices. The price isn’t anything special and does nothing to really sell the Premium service. A downside is that you have to sync offline music every 30 days and there is no official BlackBerry app. Spotify should be your pick if you want to be able to listen to your stations offline.
  • Google Play Music All Access - GPMAA has a huge advantage of being able to upload 20,000 of your own songs to cloud storage and download it to other computers. Keep in mind that this great feature is also part of the core free version. The music quality is very high and if you sign up early the discount will be worth it. GPMAA doesn’t have it's own social features and doesn’t have as many apps, but this is likely because it’s so new. GPMAA should be your pick if you have a large library of songs and want to store them across the cloud, and music discovery is secondary.
  • Rdio Unlimited - Rdio’s wins in price if you enter an Unlimited Family plan with a few friends. Its ability to review songs makes Rdio’s social features slightly edge out Spotify. Rdio does lose out on not having a specified bitrate and an inability to sync offline to computers. Rdio should be your pick if you want your music to have a great social experience.

Do you prefer high quality sound files, online storage, offline capabilities, multiple app support, or social interaction? We’ve given you the reasons you should and shouldn’t use each music service, now it’s your choice to decide which is best for you.

Commented

  • Dave |
    09/06/13
    Dave

    Thanks for the analysis--I've used all of them and I'm leaning towards Google right now, but the fact that you cannot listen offline on a computer is a big problem for me.

    I frequently go camping and setup ALL of my music offline from whatever service, and if I'm limited to my phone or tablet to do this, it's kinda useless....since the storage is limited.

  • abel delelegn |
    09/06/13
    abel delelegn

    it is good

  • Rick Steves |
    11/06/13
    Rick Steves

    Rdio's mobile app is beautiful, also for me offline syncing is a must. I'm sticking with it.

  • TM |
    25/06/13
    TM

    Rdio has been a great service for me; though, I am happy to switch if somebody proves the move is worthwhile. Rdio has an excellent interface and they offer a great way to explore new music. They are really oriented to music fans who love are "album listeners." I am very happy and just wish more people would join to expand the social sharing/sourcing aspect to explore music. So far the biggest downside has been their inability to access british labels (so some "big name" music is not available: Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, etc). But they win out for the time being.

  • Nicole |
    27/06/13
    Nicole

    I started with Spotify, am obsessed and have gotten a ton of other friends and users to use it as well. I checked out Rdio after Spotify and wasn't really super impressed. I think it'd be a great service if I didn't already have spotify, but now that I have a ton of playlists, followers on playlists, offline syncing, etc, there's nothing compelling enough for me to switch. The $9.99 with offline syncing, unlimited streaming and no commercials is a no brainer for me. As for the music I can't get, I just add that to my iTunes library and listen to it the "old fashioned" way :)

  • Nesly Lacroix |
    04/07/13
    Nesly Lacroix

    One category the author failed to compare is the ecosystem of each service. Spotify leads in in this one as the desktop app has a catalog of apps you can intall and do some nifty things with. Last.fm, Soundrop, Playmysong are just a few. There are many 3rd party support for Spotify.

  • Anon |
    16/07/13
    Anon

    No mention of the fact that spotify relies on p2p sharing for their desktop application

  • lucynlou |
    30/07/13
    lucynlou

    Which one pays a bigger amount in royalty fees to the artists?

  • D |
    09/08/13
    D

    Artist/label fees are pretty standard so don't expect much of a difference on the total amount going to artists each month, at least for the mechanical copyright.

  • john |
    14/09/13
    john

    can you burn the music to cd's

29/07/14
Your avatar