Which iPod music ripper for Mac? Senuti versus iPodRip

Senuti logoiPodRip logo

In the world of iPods and iPhones, there’s nothing more annoying than not being able to copy your music from them onto your hard drive. This is because Apple have locked both devices so that you can only copy music onto them but not vice-versa. This is incredibly frustrating if you want to replace a song you’ve lost or deleted in iTunes, your Mac has crashed and your iPod/iPhone is the only place you’ve saved your music, or if you simply want to transfer some songs between computers.

Fortunately, there are two excellent “unlocking” solutions for Mac in the form of Senuti and iPodRip. Both applications used to be free but now require a modest fee to use them. Both have free trial versions however and I put them both through their paces to see which is best.

Senuti

Firstly, Senuti supports both iPod and iPhones so if you own the latter as well, then it’s a no-brainer which to choose. The interface of Senuti is very clean and as soon as you connect your iPod, your music and playlists appear pretty much instantly. To transfer a song, you can either drag and drop them or select the song and click the clearly labeled “Transfer” button in the top left corner.

senuti screenshot

That’s about all there is to it. Once a track is transferred, it is denoted with a blue dot which tells you that it has already been transferred to your hard drive. You can also play songs simply by double clicking on them. The demo is limited to 30 days and 1000 song transfers but there’s no nag screen and the full license costs $18.

Score: 9/10

iPodRip

Don’t be fooled by the name because iPodRip supports both iPods and iPhones and does the same job as Senuti equally well. The interface I found a little less easy on the eye with the “Transfer” button replaced by a more discreet “Import” button at the bottom of the interface. Unlike with Senuti, you can’t stop transfers once they’ve started either. Once a track has been imported, a green tick appears next to the song rather than a blue dot as in Senuti which I think is marginally more logical.

iPodRip screenshot

In terms of speed however, it’s almost exactly the same as Senuti. The most annoying thing about iPodRip is the registration nag screen that floats next to the interface. There is no time limit to the trial period but the demo is limited to just 100 transfers. iPodRip costs $19.95 with an additional fee of $9.95 applied to household licenses (5 Macs or more). However, if you join their Facebook page, you can get 10% of this price.

Score: 8/10

Overall, in view of the slightly slicker interface, lack of nag screen and generous 1000 song demo limit, I’ve plumped for Senuti. It’s also slightly cheaper for an individual license although if you need to install one of the two apps across several computers, the household license on iPodRip will certainly work out cheaper. Finally, I should mention that there are several other worthwhile (and some free) solutions out there including YamiPod, Pod to Mac, PodView and Diskaid.

Loading comments